By 1972, people stopped caring about Tim Hardin records, or at least that's what it seems like whenever trying to sell any one of his releases after "Tim Hardin 4." But if you did happen to pick up a copy of 1972's "Painted Head," you will have heard Tim cover not one but two Badfinger songs, both featuring Peter Frampton on guitar.
Neither of Hardin's covers are better than the originals. But there is something very effective about "Midnight Caller." His version of "Perfection," from Badfinger's "Straight Up" on the other hand, is a huge misstep.
Check'em out.
oy vey, what he did!
ReplyDeleteI seem to remember that Rod Stewart’s version of “Reason to Believe” sparked a little bit of interest in Hardin. Didn’t last long, I don’t think.
ReplyDeleteFirst two Tim Hardin records are essential and light years ahead of these two cover versions.
ReplyDeletei blame it on the producer (tho Hardin was a hard case) - wth was he doing pushing a Badfinger cover when he botched his one shot with the Beatles in the early 60's
ReplyDeleteHe wrote at least a dozen of memorable songs that are just well written, produced and sung songs. I will never tire of hearing Don't Make Promises.
ReplyDeleteSaw Hardin perform solo at a tiny university auditorium around 1977. Maybe 150 people in attendance. Concert was extremely uneven, but when he performed his better known songs, it was magical.
ReplyDeleteI think this is the first time I've heard his voice. I don't know his music at all. Both cuts are pretty bad, but "Midnight Caller" is less awkward.
ReplyDelete8 out of 10 for the title...:)
ReplyDeleteFascinating! And Frampton on guitar - wow. I didn't realize he did any moonlighting gigs outside of the Pie and his solo work.
ReplyDeleteFrampton made a lot of guest appearances, including Nilsson, John Entwistle's "Whistle Rhymes," Donovan records, Sly Stone. His list of credits is looooong!
DeleteOh, but you ARE a badfinger!
ReplyDelete