Musician Chris Church reminded me that Tin Machine was released on this day, 5/22 in 1989. Here's what he had to say:
"The self-titled debut by Tin Machine was released on May 22 in 1989. I never understood or cared about the negative things that some people (even David Bowie's own fans, who seemingly are supposed to have supported his often drastic artistic turns) have said about this album over the years. I made my mind up right away and my opinion is strongly reinforced every time I listen. I frikkin love it. Bowie wanted to play guitar and be in a loud rock band, but it's still sophisticated and whip smart. I don't know if the haters even listened to it. Yes, I'll always love "Hunky Dory," "Scary Monsters," "Low," etc... I love so much of his wonderful, unique music, but most days, this one is my absolute favorite. The Sales Brothers' rhythm section is a thrill ride (opening track "Heaven's In Here" is as exciting and in the moment as rock music can be), Bowie sounds completely engaged - and when the song calls for it, properly artfully disengaged (see the brilliant "I Can't Read.") Reeves Gabrels is a guitar monster on a rampage (every damn song). Disagree all you want, it doesn't matter at all to me. This. Album. ROCKS."
I can't say I disagree with any of this.
But I added this:
On
May 31st, 1989, the first (and only) International Rock Awards were held
in NYC. The Replacements, Living Colour, Keith Richards and David Bowie
were the musical acts I can remember. But it wasn't Bowie, it was the
debut of Tin Machine. They played "Heaven's In Here" and it blew my
mind. A few days later, while on my way to work, I notice these posters
plasted all over buildings. They had a silhouette of four bodies
standing and leaning, and again, if memory serves, nothing but "THE
WORLD" was written below the silhouettes. The World was a short-lived,
hole in the wall rock club on the Lower East Side. After some sleuthing,
me and some co-workers figured it out. We got on a line with the other
diehards and got to see Tin Machine in a very small room, blow our faces out. I have loved
this record ever since.
I also wrote this on May 22nd, 2019:
On this day, 30 years ago, David Bowie unleashed Tin Machine's debut
record into the world. Misunderstood from day one, and still considered
one of the low points in Bowie's career, Tin Machine confused almost
everyone. But not me. I loved it.
The music on Tin Machine's debut is metallic. It's both art rock and
punk rock. It has some amazing music on it, as well as some true crap.
As All Music writes, "A remarkable recording for many reasons, the debut
of Tin Machine predates by nearly half a decade, much of the
guitar-oriented alternative pop that followed the grunge explosion of
1991-1992. This record would have been more popular had it been released
five or six years later"
The problem with the record is that it is unsure of what it wants to be.
Bowie wanted it to be a band, so drummer Hunt Sales gets to sing a bit.
Bowie also gives the spotlight, more often than not, to guitarist
Reeves Gabrels, who shines at times, but also occasionally overplays to
an uncomfortable extent. With the exception of the brilliant "I Can't
Read," a song that remained in Bowie's setlist years later, little
sounded like anything Bowie had done prior. The same could be said for
just about every record Bowie had released from 1966 until his death 50
years later. It's just that this time, in 1989, after the huge MTV
success of "Let's Dance" and "Blue Jean," the blame went on Gabrels and
the Sales brothers and few took to the maniacal sounds emanating from
those grooves.
And I wrote this back in October of 2025:
I can't help but think if Tin Machine was a band of four unknowns, their debut record would be considered a classic instead of a lemon. The record is flawed, no question. Lyrically, it can be cringemaking at times. But it also has moments of raw power and unmitigated audacity. Tin Machine's 1989 debut is manic and unruly for all the right reasons. It's loud and it's grimy. It's four guys throwing shit against a wall and hoping some of it sticks. And what sticks and what doesn't, depends on where you are standing.
I love this record and I think more people could feel like I do if they dropped the baggage. Even if you hate David Bowie, this resembles nothing in Bowie's catalogue. And if you love Soupy Sales, this doesn't sound like him either.
And so, for its 37th birthday, I suggest listening to Tin Machine, either for the first time or again. It's time.
Yeah, but can you dance "The Mouse" to any of it? 😎
ReplyDeleteA few whiskeys and you’re singing “Pachalafaka” to any track on Side Two.
DeleteI'd love to see Pookie in his window doing "Bus Stop" with Soupy!
DeleteBowie lost me for a period but I gave these 2 tracks a listen. As usual per Bowie the production is top notch. As his albums go it's a shame I overlooked it. If I was 38 again I probably would have bought this.
ReplyDeleteNot particularly my cuppa now or then, but I thought it was kind of interesting in the abstract, and was grateful that Bowie's singing was so much less mannered than normal.
ReplyDeleteSteve what was your Bowie "cuppa" tea.
ReplyDeleteCurious minds want to know 😉
"Rebel Rebel." "All the Young Dudes." "Under Pressure." That's about it, actually.
DeleteOh, and "Heroes."
ReplyDeleteCan never get enough of the “I kinda think Bowie stinks” commentary on the pages of a “Bowie is a genius” leaning blog. 😬
ReplyDeleteHey, you gotta give me points for consistency. 😎
DeleteI feel proud that I gave Tin Machine a chance, even if it was belatedly. I tried, I really tried.
ReplyDeleteI bought the debut upon its release and played in heavy rotation for a bit as a big fan. I thought it was arguably the best and most interesting album Bowie had done in a while. But, eventually it fell out of the rotation and was filed away where it falls victim to Bowie’s outstanding catalog - even BW ranks 22 albums better (recall Rough Trade ranked every Bowie album better. Lol!). I’m always grateful when you mention it as a reminder. He seemed to initiate his creative recovery with this album. I thought it was cool that the band would cover Roxy Music’s “If There Is Something”. That Pearl Jam would use the album’s producer Tim Palmer to mix their debut, Ten shortly afterwards suggests that perhaps Bowie was onto something.
ReplyDeleteI also really liked Bowie’s collaboration with Adrian Belew on “Pretty Pink Rose”, which he wrote and came out the following year.
Thanks again. #Happy Birthday :)
I lost the plot on Prince for a good while before his final 3 or 4 albums, each of which had moments of total brilliance on them. Time to re-evaluate when I lost the plot on Bowie too - thanks.
ReplyDeleteAlso, I'd forgotten how 'English' he allowed his vocals to be. It's always been weird to me that so many English singers either purpposefully or subliminally sublimate their accents when singing.
Bowie is a constantly moving target. Think you’ve got him figured out and once again he slips away.
ReplyDeleteCaptain Al
I was horrified when these first came out. I only listened again decades later at your insistence. Granted that is some garbage but there are also a bunch of ripe cherries waiting to be picked.
ReplyDeleteSide note: The beginning of Bus Stop sounds like one of our tunes, "Why Do You Lie?".
You’re probably right that if they were four unknowns releasing their first album, they would have gotten a better reception. I ignored it because I figured it was just Bowie’s latest incarnation, and the next one might be another starman.
ReplyDeleteI liked the first two songs, didn’t care much for “I Can’t Read”, so yeah, it’s time to give the full album a listen.
This doesn’t sound like Soupy Sales, either- it’s the country version of “Bus Stop”!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=86_8RLcIjVk&list=RD86_8RLcIjVk&start_radio=1
I loved this album from day one.
ReplyDelete