"Pet Sounds" will be celebrating 60 years come May and so, why not reissue the record yet again? This time there will be a number of options, including a "definitive sound" edition for $100, making all previous "definitive" editions...umm...undefinitive. There will be a 2 LP set featuring both a stereo and mono mix. There will be a sessions set featuring a cappella tracks, alternates, etc.. And there will be a special Zoetrope vinyl edition which plays the audio from "Pet Sounds" while showing visuals from Coppola's "Rumble Fish" A good time is guaranteed for all.
Taken whole, it's hard to argue the brilliance of "Pet Sounds," but I will anyway. First, I've ranked the songs on "Pet Sounds" from favorite to least favorite.
God Only Knows
Caroline, No
Wouldn't It Be Nice
Don't Talk
I Just Wasn't Made For These Times
You Still Believe In Me
Sloop John B
Here Today
Let's Go Away For Awhile
I Know There's An Answer
I'm Waiting For The Day
Pet Sounds
That's Not Me
The issue I've always had with "Pet Sounds" is that there are far better songs on other Beach Boys records than these seven:
Sloop John B
Let's Go Away For Awhile
I Know There's An Answer
I'm Waiting For The Day
Here Today
Pet Sounds
That's Not Me
Take these four from "Today," for instance.
When I Grow Up
Please Let Me Wonder
Kiss Me Baby
She Knows Me Too Well
Or, these four from "Summer Days."
Girl Don't Tell Me
California Girls
Let Him Run Wild
You're So Good To Me
The problem is, the rest of the tracks on "Summer Days" and "Today" can't hold a candle to any of the 13 on "Pet Sounds," not even the two instrumentals, which I think are gorgeous.
If asked what my favorite Beach Boys album was, I'd say "Pet Sounds" in a flash. If asked for my favorite records of all time, "Pet Sounds" would be in the Top 20. And though I reach for both "Summer Days" and "Today" more often than "Pet Sounds," I don't think either would even crack my Top 100 of all time.
How's that for confusing?