At some point many moons ago, I wrote about "Clubland," a song by Elvis Costello that for me, is the very definition of Elvis Costello. I said something like, "If you put ten songwriters in a room and asked them to write an Elvis Costello song, it would come out sounding like 'Clubland.'"
It's an odd concept, especially when Costello, possibly more than any other artist, has jumped genres so often, anything from alt-country to classical could define a particular patch of his career. Yet, "Clubland," released at the peak of his powers, give or take, simply sounds like everything I want from the man.
This idea came back to me a few days ago, while discussing the band Queen with a friend. He stands by the first six albums, but then got off the bus at "Jazz." I happen to love "Jazz," so I got off the bus at "Hot Space." But now, over 30 years after Freddie Mercury's death, I've come to appreciate all of Queen's music. Those last few records, from "A Kind Of Magic" to "Innuendo," have some pretty awful music on them. But knowing more now about Freddie's wild life and his wanting more of everything all of the time, helped me accept more of those crazy, over the top dancey bits on those albums.
Still, if I had to pick one song that defines Queen, it would be "The March Of The Black Queen" from their second album. Like "Clubland," this song sounds like everything I want from the band. It was released a little under two years before Freddie foisted "Bohemian Rhapsody" on the world, and in some ways it's the template, with numerous sections, vocal flourishes and driving guitars. It's Queen already outdoing Queen and they've only just gotten started.
So kids, can you pick just one song that for you, represents all that you love about an artist or band?
I don't mind if you choose ten artists, as long as you keep it to one song per artist. This is a song, one song, that will represent the talent scouts on another planet. One song, that will make people who have never heard a single note by Elvis Costello or Queen, say, "I want more of this" after only hearing "Clubland" and "The March Of The Queen." And I should point out, the song you choose doesn't necessarily need to be your favorite song by the artist.
34 comments:
The Byrds -- "The World Turns All Around Her." Springsteen -- "Rosalita" Those work for me. 😎
"Out On The Weekend" by Neil Young. "Racing In The Streets" by Bruce Springsteen. "Do kanns zaubre" by BAP. "Babylon's Burning" by The Ruts. "Geno" by Dexy's Midnight Runners ......
Sorry, forgot to add my name
wimp
Springsteen Thundercrack
Guy Clark Boats To Build
Gomez Options
Del Amitri Not Where It's At
Box Tips Soul Deep
The Connells Still Life
Dave Clark Five Everybody Knows
Dr. Dog Stranger
Dwight Yoakam A Thousand Miles From Nowhere
Elvis Costello New Lace Sleeves
Everything But The Girl Wrong
Frank Zappa Inca Roads
Mott The Hoople All The Way From Memphis
Sorry, I could do this all day
I didn't think this would be easy.
Led Zeppelin - When The Levee Breaks
I know it doesn't represent the folky, acoustic side of the band, but it just grooves with sweat, blues, and sex... and for me, that is what Led Zeppelin was all about.
Randy
"I know it doesn't represent the folky, acoustic side of the band, but it just grooves with sweat, blues, and sex... and for me, that is what Led Zeppelin was all about."
And that's the point.
Van Morrison - Caravan (I would go with the version from It's Too Late to Stop Now, but I think that is cheating).
Yes- Heart of the Sunrise
It's not easy, I picked easy ones for me. I thought "Which Robert Palmer song would I pick? Beatles? Kinks? King Crimson?" All seem too diverse to nail. I know my favorites, but the one that represents the fundamental of the artist? And by the way, the Caravan from Too Late To Stop Now is absolutely the right choice, and not cheating. For me, I need to find a Van Morrison song that threads the line between his hits and his seeker period, so maybe Real, Real Gone.
Great topic Sal.
Sleater-Kinney - I Wanna Be Your Joey Ramone
X - Johnny Hit and Run Paulene
Pixies - Gauge Away
Sinatra - Summer Wind
I've done this exercise years ago with some friends, trying to nail the 1 song that is the essence of bands I love. I can't remember them all, but here are a few:
Rush: Limelight
Crowded House: Distant Sun
Big Star: When My Baby's Beside Me
REM: Sitting Still
The Stones: Rocks Off
Fountains of Wayne: Red Dragon Tattoo
Guster: Fa Fa
Elvis C - I also picked Clubland ("The long arm of The Law slides up the outskirts of town" is an amazing line)
Robyn Hitchcock: Raymond Chandler Evening
Guided By Voices- My Kind Of Soldier
Chuck Prophet- Leave The Window Open
The Bevis Frond- Lights Are Changing
NRBQ- The Same Old Thing
Drive By Truckers- Zip City
Neil Young- Come On Baby Let’s Go Downtown
Van Morrison - Piper At The Gates Of Dawn
REM- Harborcoat
Cheap Trick- Busted
Richie Blackmore's Rainbow's "Stargazer"
If you asked me to write a Paul McCartney-like song, I"d write "Silly Love Songs" (and then get sued by Paul, but you get the idea)
As far as Elvis Costello goes--hewing to the specific criteria of what I personally like about his music as opposed to a single song that represents the entire career--I choose "Blue Chair" off of Blood and Chocolate. I feel like it could fit seamlessly on about a dozen EC albums. It's an essential track on any EC playlist I create.
You are right, though. It is a tough exercise and I've been wracking my brian to come up with more than just few. However, the few I do have were arrived without too much struggle.:
"Green River" for CCR
"American Music" for The Violent Femmes
"You're So Bad" Tom Petty
The Band - Up on Cripple Creek
Allen Toussaint - When the Party is Over
Boz Scaggs - Downright Woman
The Beatles - We Can Work it Out
Average White Band - Work to Do (yes I know this is an Isley Bros song)
Isley Brothers - This Old Heart of Mine
The Rascals - Baby Let's Wait
Let me sneak this one in here while no one is looking:
The Who- Cut My Hair
Fleshtones - New Scene
Warren Zevon - Genius
Bob Dylan - Memphis Blues Again
Tom Petty - Mary Jane's Last Dance
Doug Sahm - Texas Me
Little Feat - Easy To Slip
Pet Shop Boys - Being Boring
ELO - Can't Get It Out Of My Head
Elvis Costello - Just About Glad
Graham Parker - Stupefaction
XTC - Life Begins at the Hop
Finch
NY Dolls - Subway Train.
Lyres - Not Looking Back.
Saints - Know your Product.
Soft Boys - I Wanna Destroy You.
Hoodoo Gurus - Let's All Turn On
Comateens - Late Night City.
Motörhead - Ace of Spades.
Smithereens - Behind the Wall of Sleep.
Stray Cats - Rock this Town.
Bongos - In the Congo.
Plimsouls - Hush hush.
Real Kids - All Kindsa Girls.
Jonathan Richman/Modern Lovers - Roadrunner.
Undertones - Teenage Kicks.
Buzzcocks - What Do I Get.
J from Europe.
The Replacements - Left of the Dial
Sal, love your Who choice. Totally 100% Who. A few from me:
Elvis Costello: Man Out of Time
Randy Newman: Birmingham
Rickie Lee Jones: It Must Be Love
Warren Zevon: Hasten Down the Wind
Steely Dan: Kid Charlemagne
Gillian Welch: I Want To Sing That Rock and Roll
Velvet Underground - Heroin - the guitar solo is still the craziest thing I've heard
XTC - Senses Working Overtime
J from Europe nailed about everyone of his choices
Devo:Gut feeling/Slap your mammy
Lloyd Cole:Are you ready to be heartbroken
Belly:Gepetto
Go Betweens:Streets of your town
Greetings from Brisbane Sal
Matty Groves-Fairport Convention, Incident on 57th Street -Bruce, Rockin Chair-Band, Mississippi -Dylan, Bus Station-Dave Alvin, Dark End of the Street-James Carr, When The Healing Has Begun -Van
I'd nominate Badlands for Springsteen (Rosalita or Jungleland work too). Sheena is a Punk Rocker for the Ramones. The Body of an American for the Pogues. -- Marc
Matty Groves-Fairport Convention, Incident on 57th St-Bruce, Rockin Chair-Band, Mississippi-Dylan, 4th of July-Dave Alvin, Dark End of The Street-James Carr, When The Healing Has Begun-Van, Vast Indifference of Heaven-Zevon, Old Time Lovin-Al Green
after reading rules G Parker's "Don't ask me Questions" jumped in my head. maybe back w more
U2 - Pride
Waterboys - The Big Music
Hüsker Dü - Makes No Sense At All
New Order - Temptation
Siouxsie and the Banshees - Spellbound
- Paul in DK
+1 on Clubland
Warren Zevon- Splendid Isolation
Michael McDermott- A Wall I Must Climb
Elton John- Captain Fantastic and the Brown Dirt Cowboy
Van Morrison- And the Healing Has Begun
AC/DC - Down Payment Blues...Bon at his best and the others more than matching him...magnificent.
cool experiment..
Little Feat - On Your Way Down (live)
Level 42- Dune Tune
thanks for an interesting blog.. always something nice here
This is a tough assignment but I'll try...
Surf's Up/The Beach Boys
Gumbo Variations/Frank Zappa
Every Picture Tells A Story/Rod Stewart
Nowhere Man/The Beatles
Remember/John Lennon
Ridin' In My Car/NRBQ
And When I Die/Laura Nyro
Days/The Kinks
Reelin' In The Years/Steely Dan
Echoes/Pink Floyd
There are many other artists I would like to include on this list, but it's so impossible...I might try later.
Post a Comment