Monday, August 24, 2020

More Mellifluous Madness From The Lemon Twigs



If you had told me back in 1977 while I was blasting the first album by The Clash, that in forty years one of my favorite records was going to be a concept album about a chimp raised by humans who burns down his school, with musical nods to Big Star, Todd Rundgren, Leonard Bernstein, David Bowie and Frank Zappa, I would have called you bat shit crazy. But the impossible did indeed happen, and "The Lemon Twigs Go To School" was my favorite record of 2018. It was audacious and confusing, and at times, admittedly, a little annoying. But at its core was old-fashioned record making, songs with hooks and stunning harmonies, interesting solo breaks, rockers, ballads and kitchen sink production when needed. All of it, right in my wheelhouse.

The Lemon Twigs are back with record number three, and not much has changed in the last two years. Well...at least not musically. There is no concept behind "Songs For The General Public," as far as I can tell, beyond a collection of songs, though it is hard to ignore what I assume are intentional nods to many of the same artists mentioned above.

The album opens with "Hell On Wheels," and I wouldn't blame you if you packed up and went home before it ended. It's a twisted take on the Jim Steinman/Meat Loaf bombast that for me does not work and should not have opened things up. But then, I am not one of the D'Addarrio brothers, who seemingly do whatever the hell they want when they want.

If you exhibit a little patience, you will be rewarded, as the next seven or eight songs are some of the most delightful, at times beautiful, and yes, often twisted pop songs you are likely to hear this year. The Twigs cover all bases, with the Rundgren influences coming through strong on both "Fight," which sounds like a long lost Utopia single from the early 80's, and "Only A Fool," which goes back a bit earlier to Utopia's slightly proggier years.  "Moon" feels like it was pulled right out of Bruce's "Born To Run" sessions, and "Somebody Loving You," is a song that Freddie Mercury used to write in his sleep before the disco era.

Michael & Brian D'Addario are 21 and 23, respectively, and what they have created in the last 5 years is nothing short of astonishing, even if the music isn't quite as easy to swallow as you'd like it to be. Much of it makes little sense on the outside. Why the glammy album cover when there is nothing particularly glammy about anything inside? Why the silly Zappa-esque lyrics over a gorgeous pop ballad? These things might be speed bumps for some, but if it draws enough attention to what is really important, the depth of the record making, then I am all for it.

The Lemon Twigs are sure different, but most of the time, it's different in all the best ways. Personally, I don't need another power pop album that gets compared to Jellyfish or Big Star. But, I'll take one that sounds like Big Star doing Springsteen! Or Rundgren doing Zappa!

"Songs For The General Public" is another winner. Just give it the time it deserves.







10 comments:

cmealha said...

Really looking forward to getting my copy od the vinyl and spending some quality time with the D'Addario brothers and all their glorious weirdness.

Bill said...

Just listened to Songs for the General Public thanks to your post and I liked it quite a bit--even that first song. I am hearing some glam influences, and a touch of Ween in a couple of places--as well as those other influences you mention. Will seek out their earlier LPs too.

buzzbabyjesus said...

The first one disappointed me, but the next Ep and "School" are still getting play over here. I'll probably even like the opener.

paulinca said...

Well, I was today years old hearing these guys for the first time and they ROCK!!! Love the derivative influences, love the energy and the power pop sound. Great band!

paulinca

Todd said...

I noticed the cover photo, like the music itself, is off-center!

Michael Giltz said...

Obviously the music led to your comment, but multiple shout-outs to Utopia have me wondering when we'll get your round-up of The Todd's band discography. Are we ever sated? No we are not. After that we'll want a Hall & Oates run-down a la your Todd-A-Thon and then who knows. But we'll always want more!

cmealha said...

I couldn't wait until Thursday for my vinyl to arrive so I downloaded the album from Apple.

For the most part it does not disappoint. A lot of high points with a couple of misses but so far very satisfying. The sound is incredible and I'm sure they recorded it in their bathroom or some such location. (Bastards!)

My absolute favorite is "Somebody Loving You" with harmonies that would have made the Beach Boys proud. "Live in Favor of Tomorrow", "No One Holds You...", "The One", "Why Do Lovers Own Each Other?" round out my other faves. Lots of recognizable influences from Todd, Roy Wood, Mr. Rogers and more. "Why Do Lovers...' could have been a Pet Sounds outtake.

Not bothered by "Helen Wheels". Neither yay or nay, just OK. The jury is still out on "Only a Fool." Not sure whether to give them props or discard it as a bad prog attempt a la Field Music on everything but "Commontime."

The only songs I truly don't care for are the last two, "Leather Together" and "Ashamed." Given the rest of the album, they were disappointments but their at the end so easily skipped.

And then there's "Hog." Both one of my favorites and one of the worst. A beautiful song with very weird and disconcerting lyrics. Makes me glad they live on the East Coast. But it works in a very twisted way. What doesn't is the middle part. It's so jarring and out of context. I was truly perplexed and angry that they basically ruined the song that way. But I created an edited version which eliminates the middle and it truly is a standout. Maybe my second favorite.

They have a masterpiece in them but I don't think this is it yet. They're on their way and hopefully will continue to mature and improve. The fact that they're so young is unbelievable to me. Looking forward to more and more.

cmealha said...

Just a thought. Imagine Ian Hunter with Mott the Hoople doing "Hell on Wheels".

Sal Nunziato said...

"Just a thought. Imagine Ian Hunter with Mott the Hoople doing "Hell on Wheels"."

Yep! Exactly. Or Bowie! Ian and Bowie would sell it. Brian D'Addario is not selling it. I find the fake southern accent and fale Dylan impersonations...well...fake. It's why I posted the duo version you sent from Seth Myers. You can hear a great song.

heartsofstone said...

Thanks for the insight. I agree entirely about the Seth Myers version redeeming the song by stripping away the affectations. I cut them a lot of slack given their ages. They are making huge strides with every release, even if it doesn't all work.